calwages.com

Archive for the ‘Press Quotes’ Category

Press Quotes About Analysis of Ninth Circuit’s Kilgore v. KeyBank, N.A. Case

In Arbitration, Injunctive Relief, Press Quotes, Public Claims on April 15, 2013 at 9:15 am
ProfWhiteboard_Injunctions

ProfWhiteboard_Injunctions (Photo credit: cali.org)

Abigail Rubenstein of Law360 published an article Friday quoting the blog author’s analysis of the Ninth Circuit’s recent en banc ruling in Kilgore v. KeyBank, N.A.  Kilgore v. Keybank, N.A., No. 09-16703, __ F.3d __ (9th Cir. Apr. 11, 2013) (en banc):

Employers who were hoping that the full court would adopt the original appellate panel in the case’s flat-out rejection of the Broughton-Cruz rule may be disappointed, but the narrower en banc decision will still likely prove useful to businesses trying to enforce their arbitration agreements in employment disputes, lawyers told Law360.

“The decision left open the question of the viability of the Broughton-Cruz rule, but the reasoning of the court at the end of the day might please the defense bar more than the plaintiffs bar because although the Ninth Circuit sidestepped the continued viability of the rule, what it did say was that to extent that an exception [to the FAA] for public injunctive relief exists, it is quite a narrow one,” Charles Jung of Nassiri & Jung LLP said.

And employers facing Private Attorney General Act claims, which plaintiffs often argue fit into that exception, can seize on the appeals court’s narrow construction to make the case that the claims should be sent to an arbitrator, employment defense lawyers said.